Ok, so you're definantly more art oriented than you are design oriented. The main thing you have to remember is to simplify things. With this piece it's hard to tell what the point of the sig is. There is more emphasis on Marcus and the spartan than there is on the xbox. There are to many colors and to many things going on at once. It might look better if these were split into 3 different images.
Many members have been on a break and we could always use help with sigs. I want to see you try some requests. I don't want you to post any of them without my say so first though. Try to find some requests that aren't filled and do the requests. Post the image you make and a link to the request. If it is deemed good enough I'll let you post it. (This doesn't mean you're on the team yet since it's not up to me, but you're so active you might as well help us out. Doing requests might even help you grow with your art).
try to make your borders smaller. 2-3 pixels is enough.
To be honest and this is just me not all the sigs need to have a border I find it simpler is essentially better I mean the border does give it a certain look but without the border being around the pic and giving it that slight distraction the picture looks better without the border around cutting the edges of the pic. Also for this pic I see alot going on lol it's hard to really tell where the flow starts and stops ya know since it's so cluttered, with this type of sig (more than 1 focal) it's hard to really get 2 or more focals to not look cluttered especially if they are two different renders. Main thing is to figure out how you can make it flow well in this case with the render on the left I would've put his back to the other guy to make it seem like thats his right hand man, also the second guy looks like the background and the guy are all one? If thats the case then you could've slightly gausian blurred it around 0.5 to 0.6 and put the other guy on the right hand side since it wouldnt take up so much of whats going on on that side. Cause it looks like on the left side there's a lil more going on plus you don't want to clutter one side of area you kind of want to utilize the space to the best of your ability. It's a decent sig tho, keep up the good work.
Ok so with this one it's not bad but it's noticeable that this is the whole picture and not a render, to be honest I'd steer away from doing this not only is it hard to design over that but it doesn't give you too much free creative room. When designing a sig or banner it's basically taking a pic you like and making your own version of it. In this case if this is the pic the person choose I would have definitely slightly blurred the background a lil bit with the blur tool around 10 or 5% opacity, I would have also slightly blurred the corners of the picture and sharpened the girl to really make her stand out in the picture making it seem like you're automatically focusing on her as you see her nothing else comes into focus at least around her the bed or whatever can be focused.
Ok so for this type of sig I've done one before and it's a tad bit difficult cause you can't take away from the original pic because the original is essentially what you need for a city sig you need the city lol. But what I did was use different backgrounds to give it some slight effects. But the main thing I notice is the Text, nothing really wrong with it but one this for sure and I use to do it as well which I'm sure everyone has and thats not putting everything in the same type of text. What I do is usually pick an awesome text that looks good with the name then with everything else I use a simple plain text, I find doing that not only makes the Text for the name pop but also organizes it a lil and makes it neater looking and not make it as cluttered vs using the same font for everything.
Can you please include the original stock/render when posting your completed requests, thank you.
Looking much better with these. Keep up,the good work, and remember to,only use the best quality images