i see your point, but do you agree how confusing it would be if say someone went offline for a long period of time say a council member or a pro gamer, then someone else nabbed their gamertag the second it was available... that's like identity fraud, and i believe that's y they don't recycle them... i.e. XGC Knight XI hasn't been around for a long time now, and i'm sure his gold tag is expired, if someone picked that up, he could confuse and trick a lot of people